ACT Seminar with Dr. Rachael Walsh (Trinity College Dublin)
Constitutional Property and Progressive Property – A Compatibility Assessment
Dr. Rachael Walsh joins ACT's seminar series on 28 March 15.30-17.00 with her talk, "Constitutional Property and Progressive Property – A Compatibility Assessment."
Event details from: ACT Seminar with Dr. Rachael Walsh (Trinity College Dublin)
- Date
- 28 March 2022
- Time
- 15:30 – 17:00

Abstract:
This paper develops a thesis about the political effects of property rights guarantees that builds on themes in Property Rights and Social Justice: Progressive Property in Action (CUP, 2021). It contends that judges are generally disinclined, for institutional reasons, to clearly articulate reasons for their decisions on the core distributive dilemmas that are inevitably raised by property rights guarantees. This leads to vagueness in the relevant property rules, particularly in respect of: a) what distribution of collective burdens is susceptible to invalidation pursuant to such guarantees; b) when compensation might be required to legitimise property rights restrictions. Such ambiguity in turn has the effect of supporting political cultures that overinflate the strength of constitutional protection for property rights.
Progressive property theory is at its core characterised by a desire to improve the law, and legal outcomes, for those on the margins of society. At the same time, it largely assumes the compatibility of constitutional property rights with its aims. Given the chilling effect that constitutional property law has on legislative changes that interfere with property rights, the paper argues that progressive property should be more sceptical of property rights guarantees, challenging their existence in legal orders rather than simply seeking to reinterpret constitutional property doctrine in a more progressive direction. At the very least, it should analyse and account for the political effects of such rights on the overall agenda for legal change that it advances.
About the speaker:
Dr Rachael Walsh is Assistant Professor at the School of Law, Trinity College Dublin, researching and teaching on the interface between public and private law in the context of property. She is the author of Property Rights and Social Justice: Progressive Property in Action (Cambridge University Press, 2021) and Kelly: The Irish Constitution (Bloomsbury, 2018).
Practicalities:
This seminar will be online. Upon registration, you will receive the zoom link in your confirmation email.