Meat the Law V
Subcontracted racial capitalism, organising and resistance in the meat industry: experiences from Italy and Spain
Meat the Law is a series of discussion events focusing on different dimensions of environmental and social sustainability in meat production globally. Important challenges related to production and consumption of meat remain: for instance, livestock is the single biggest contributor to global food emissions and industrial meat production in many countries has become infamous due to notorious worker rights violations. Most of the structures that enable these unsustainable practices in the meat industry are products of private law arrangements and public law regulation (or the lack thereof). The Meat the Law series seeks to strike a conversation between private law and a diversity of other approaches in order to understand and tackle the present destructive potential of the meat industry for environment, workers and society at large.
Event details from: Meat the Law V
- Date
- 10 January 2022
- Time
- 15:30 – 17:00
This session of the Meat the Law series is dedicated to the questions of how race is entangled with forms of subcontracting in the construction and sustaining of exploitable labour in parts of the European meat industry. Moreover, the speakers share examples of and reflect on different pathways of resistance that might offset current structures and practices of exploitation. Systemic reliance of the industry on migrant work has been a shared feature of industrial meat production in many European countries (Germany, the Netherlands, Italy, Spain etc.). The majority of the workforce being migrant workers, combined with different legal models of outsourcing through subcontracting of almost all parts of production, have created perfect conditions for constructing and sustaining precarious and easily exploitable labour in slaughterhouses and meat processing plants.
The discussion opens with reflections on the current working conditions in the Italian meat industry, which Piro and Sacchetto describe as a form of subcontracted racial capitalism. After addressing the entanglements between different methods of outsourcing (for example, the abuse of the ‘cooperative’ form in subcontracting chains) and racialisation, the discussion proceeds with exploring different strategies used by unions and labour activists to organise workers and initiate collective actions to challenge the current structures of exploitation. Examples of ongoing worker struggles in Northern Italy and recent strikes in the meat sector in Catalonia (Spain) respectively demonstrate challenges and successes in regional attempts of organising and resistance against injustice in the meat industry.
Presentations
Subcontracted racial capitalism: the interrelationship of race and production in meat processing plants
Valeria Piro, University of Milan; Devi Sacchetto, University of Padua
The aim of the presentation is to extend the discussion on subcontracted labour by focusing on the labour process and on the role of race and racialization within it. The existing literature has so far analysed the factors that have encouraged employer decisions to outsource labour, together with its effects on labour conditions and on industrial relations. Missing, however, has been any detailed analysis of the role of race and racialization processes, pivotal elements in the facilitation of subcontracting thereby accelerating the worsening of labour conditions. Based on qualitative empirical research on the meat industry in Northern Italy, this presentation highlights how the processes of outsourcing and racialization intersect to support the segmentation of labour within the workplace. In particular, we argue that, through contracting out work to racialized groups of migrant workers, outsourcing has been both facilitated and legitimized. Furthermore, the presence of in-plant contractors has fostered the implementation of racializing practices, which in turn have bolstered workforce fragmentation on racial lines. Notwithstanding this, our findings show that race can be a factor in the mobilization of subcontracted migrant labour through the production of pragmatic (racial) solidarities. These informal ties are a key component in the development of the everyday struggles and alliances that emerge within grass roots worker organisations as well as beyond their boundaries through hybrid forms of collective organisation.
The presentation is based on the article: Piro V and Sacchetto D, ‘Subcontracted Racial Capitalism: The Interrelationship of Race and Production in Meat Processing Plants’ (2021) 1 Work in the Global Economy 1-2. Available at: https://www.ingentaconnect.com/content/bup/wge/2021/00000001/f0020001/art00003
Organising, resistance and collective struggles in Northern Italy
Sergio Zulian, ADL COBAS (independent grassroot union active in the North East of Italy)
The focus of the intervention is to explain some of the ways in which an independent union organises workers in Northern Italy. The presentation reflects on challenges posed by subcontracted labour, especially using the form of ‘cooperatives’, combined with the dominant presence of migrant workers in the industry. The presentation looks into elements of systemic exploitation, precariousness of labour contracts and will critically examine the role of “institutional unions” in legitimizing the present system. The intervention explains how meat companies, cooperatives, trade unions and migrant communities are entangled in the production chain in specific ways which allow the complete control of employers over workers. The presentation concludes with reflections on the lack of workplace democracy and the necessity of organise workers through operations that go continuously inside and outside the workplace.
Organising and collective action in the Catalonian meat sector
Mónica Gómez, CCOO (Confederación Sindical de Comisiones Obreras / Trade Union Confederation of Workers' Commissions)
With this presentation, CCOO Industry Catalonia would like to share a trade union experience in a relevant sector for our industry where precarious employment was established: the meat sector. Thanks to a strategy of trade union action at all levels (political, judicial, workplaces) it has been possible to recognise the employment relationship of thousands of workers with the companies they work for and to dismantle false cooperatives. Despite these important achievements, we still have a long way to go until we manage to repeal the labour reform that allows the use of multi-service companies to avoid labour contracts and that company agreements with worse conditions are above sector agreements. Unity is strength.
Biographies
Devi Sacchetto is Associate Professor in Sociology of Labour at the University of Padua where he is Coordinator of the PhD program in Social Sciences. His research interests concern migration and labour processes, with a particular attention to gender and race dimensions.
Valeria Piro is post-doc research fellow at the University of Milan, where she is a member of the research team of the ERC project – SHARE (Seizing the Hybrid Areas of work by Representing self-Employment). Her research interests concern migration and labour processes, and forms of organization and representation of labour.
Sergio Zulian is activist in the grassroot union ADL COBAS (Association for the Rights of Workers). ADL COBAS is an independent union, active mainly in the North East of Italy. The Union has been developing important struggles mainly in the Transport and Logistics Sector for years, in which migrant workers constitute the majority of the workforce. ADL COBAS has developed significant struggles in other sectors such as Tourism, Cleaning, Meat etc., and has also led important struggles for the right of housing, documents of migrant workers and against racism.
Mónica Gómez is head of International and European Works Councils for the Industry Federation of CCOO (Confederación Sindical de Comisiones Obreras) Catalonia. In addition to her trade union responsibilities, she is IndustriALL Coordinator for the European Works Council of General Electric Renewables and union coordinator for Gates Forum, as well as a member of ISDIN Works Council for more than 10 years.
Contact
Organiser: Vladimir Bogoeski, Centre for Transformative Private Law, University of Amsterdam
For questions, please send an email to v.bogoeski(at)uva.nl
Practicalities
Please register via Eventbrite using the button below. You will recieve the zoom link in your confirmation email.